The path that brought Arab Strap from respectable indie rock band to leaders of a multiform rock is definitely interesting and meritorious and placed them at the center of a scene that kicks between genres to overcome labels. Scottish Aidan Moffat and Malcom Middleton over the years have preferred experimentation to custom, openness to confirmation and their music has evolved while maintaining a point of reference in acid criticism to the twists of Western society.

Their return in 2021 after 15 years from their breakup with As Days get Dark left many fans and commentators surprised because it was a powerful record in which electronics, dance music and guitar indie rock overlapped and alternated in powerful songs while Aidan sang troubled lives and insignificant characters. In 2024 I’m Totally Fine with it I don’t Give a Fuck Anymore confirmed musical research in laminated songs where guitar and synth danced under sharp lyrics, manifesting the duo’s will to make the listener move physically and not only with thought. They were two remarkable albums not surprisingly successful in public and press.

The new work, Half-Told Tales (out for Rock Action) returns them in shape and increasingly wanting to propose an eclectic rock using different registers, from hard rock to electronic dance. All at the service of a speech against the horrors of a decadent society that presents the bill to generations of social network users. The point is that eclecticism can become a formula: it is an album that paradoxically becomes predictable and above all holds well in some moments while some songs do not hold the intention.

The initial “I Get Noise” bets on a powerful drumming and harsh electric guitar while a saxophone comes out of who knows where to create disorder. Aidan’s spoken word is an act of accusation until it explodes in a cry: “But you pollute my air You’re in my head, my hair. My dreams, my thoughts, my prayers. You overshare and overbear. Now listen”. “You You You”, the radio single, stands on a synth pop structure with a powerful bass line and a 4/4 that makes dancing easily. The song has several layers, including wild guitars and airy synths, and comes to a convincing refrain. Something that in other times would get number one in charts. “Fighting For You” is a power rock hammer with a powerful shot, a captivating riff and guitar layers involving the listener. Until the sixth song the level is high and listening is intense, then something is lost and the next songs do not hold the pace in the same way, showing a little tired. A good example is “Ampersand“, a concession to old fans who will love this slow and painful ballad, but compared to the first half of the album loses the challenge of surprising the listener.

Arab Strap remain points of reference of an alternative way of playing rock and the album however deserves a careful and open listening to appreciate all the nuances of an always high-level songwriting.